Startups thrive on flexibility, and independent contractors often feel like the perfect solution. But the distinction between contractor and employee carries real legal weight. Get it wrong, and your company could face IRS audits, back taxes, wage penalties, and even personal liability.
The Legal Test: It’s About Control
Multiple government agencies use different tests, but they all look at control. Key factors include:
- Behavioral control: Do you dictate how, when, or where the work is done?
- Financial control: Do you reimburse expenses or provide tools?
- Relationship nature: Is the engagement long-term or central to your business?
If you're directing daily work and integrating the person into your team, they’re probably an employee - even if you call them a “contractor.”
Use Written Agreements - But Don’t Rely on Them Alone
A well-drafted Independent Contractor Agreement is essential. It should clearly state:
- Project-based scope of work
- No employee benefits
- Freedom over schedule and work methods
But remember: courts and agencies look at actual working conditions, not just paperwork.
Risks of Misclassification
- Back wages and taxes: You may owe overtime, unemployment taxes, and penalties.
- Liability: You could face lawsuits for wrongful termination or benefits denial.
- Investor red flags: A messy workforce structure can deter funding.
Final Thoughts
Use contractors for short-term, specialized projects - not as a workaround for full-time help. If you’re not sure about classification, talk to counsel before hiring.
Frequently Asked Questions
FAQs
What’s the biggest difference between a contractor and an employee?
Contractors control how they do their work and usually operate independently. Employees work under your direction and are integrated into your business.
Can I just call someone a contractor to avoid employment laws?
No. Classification depends on the actual working relationship, not the job title or contract language.
Why does contractor misclassification matter to investors?
It creates legal and financial liabilities. Investors want clean workforce records to avoid unexpected tax or compliance risks.
When should startups use contractors instead of employees?
Contractors are best for short-term, specialized, or non-core projects. Employees are necessary for ongoing roles central to your business.
Don't DIY your legal anymore
Leave it to the pros.